自相矛盾 zì xiāng máo dùn

The spear that pierces everything and the shield it cannot.

The short answer

自相矛盾 means to contradict yourself — literally, to turn your own spear (矛) on your own shield (盾). The Han Feizi salesman's impossible pair gave Chinese its everyday word for contradiction.

Literal: self + mutually + spear + shieldRegister: Everyday. The word 矛盾 alone does a lot of work in modern Chinese.

The story

The philosopher Han Fei tells of a man from Chu selling weapons in the market. Of his shields he said: nothing in the world can pierce them. Of his spears: they can pierce anything in the world. A bystander asked the obvious: “And if you take your spear to your shield?” The salesman could not answer.

Han Fei told it about doctrines that cannot both be true — but the arms dealer won immortality. From this single market stall Chinese derives the modern word 矛盾: contradiction.

What it means today

自相矛盾 is the standard description of inconsistent statements and people: a résumé claiming both perfectionism and easy-goingness, a policy praising thrift while spending doubles, the instant-messaging caveat that undoes the message before it.

Modern Chinese uses 矛盾 far beyond the idiom: 矛盾 is a contradiction, 有矛盾 means there is friction (between people or departments), and 心里很矛盾 means torn — wanting both things.

How to use it

Typical shape: 他先说没去过,后说去年去过,发言自相矛盾, “he first said he'd never been, then said he went last year — his statement contradicts itself”.

In use

2 examples
01

简(Jiǎn)历(lì)里(lǐ)又(yòu)说(shuō)自(zì)己(jǐ)细(xì)心(xīn),又(yòu)说(shuō)自(zì)己(jǐ)大(dà)大(da)咧(liē)咧(liē),这(zhè)不(bù)是(shì)自(zì)相(xiāng)矛(máo)盾(dùn)吗(ma)?

The résumé claims both meticulousness and being carefree — isn't that a spear against its own shield?

02

他(Tā)前(qián)后(hòu)说(shuō)法(fǎ)自(zì)相(xiāng)矛(máo)盾(dùn),很(hěn)快(kuài)就(jiù)被(bèi)人(rén)发(fā)现(xiàn)了(le)。

His statements contradicted each other, and he was caught out quickly.

The characters

Explore individually

Individual character meanings do not always explain the meaning of the whole word.

This guide is original Dengdeng editorial content, offered under CC BY-SA 4.0. The linked dictionary entries adapt CC-CEDICT under the same license.

More idiomsExplore words in context